Restorative dentistry in Guelph
Replacing metal fillings when it helps your teeth, with honest advice about when it does not.
Many adults have silver amalgam fillings placed years or even decades ago. Some are still doing their job well, while others have cracked, leaked, or left the tooth around them weakened. At Ironwood Dental in Guelph, we assess each metal filling individually and explain whether replacing it with a tooth-coloured restoration would benefit that tooth.
Reasons to replace
When replacing an old metal filling can protect the tooth.
Replacement is most helpful when a filling is failing or the tooth around it is at risk. Here is what a well-timed replacement can offer.
Addresses hidden decay
Older metal fillings can develop gaps at the edges where decay starts. Replacing a leaking filling lets us remove that decay.
Supports cracked teeth
Teeth with large amalgam fillings sometimes develop crack lines. A bonded restoration, onlay, or crown may help reinforce the tooth.
Bonded to the tooth
Tooth-coloured materials bond to enamel and dentin, which can help seal the tooth and, in some cases, require less removal of healthy structure.
A more natural look
Composite and ceramic restorations blend with your natural teeth, which many patients appreciate when they smile or laugh.
Planned at your pace
If several fillings need attention, we prioritize the ones at most risk and spread the rest over time when it is safe to do so.
Honest guidance
If a metal filling is intact and sealing well, we will tell you. Removing a healthy filling also removes some tooth structure, so we don't recommend it lightly.
How replacement works
From assessment to your new tooth-coloured restoration.
We take a measured approach, starting with the fillings that most need attention and planning the rest over time if needed.
Exam and x-rays
We look closely at each metal filling for cracks, worn edges, and staining, and use x-rays to check for decay under or between teeth.
Review the findings with you
We show you what we see, often with intraoral photos, and explain which fillings may need replacing and which can be monitored. You can ask as many questions as you need.
Plan the order
When more than one filling needs work, we decide which to replace first, usually starting with teeth that show decay, cracks, or symptoms.
Remove the old filling
With the tooth frozen, we carefully remove the amalgam using high-volume suction and water spray to keep the area clean. Any decay underneath is removed as well.
Place the new restoration
Depending on the size of the space and the strength of the remaining tooth, we place a composite filling, or plan an inlay, onlay, or crown.
Check the bite and follow up
We adjust the new restoration so your bite feels even. Some temporary sensitivity is common, and we check the tooth at future exams.

Making the decision
Signs a metal filling may need replacing, and replacement options.
Not every metal filling needs to come out. These lists help explain how we decide and what may replace it.
Signs a metal filling may need replacement
- Visible gaps or ditching around the edges of the filling
- Decay detected under or next to the filling on x-ray
- Crack lines in the tooth around the filling
- A broken or missing piece of the filling
- Sensitivity or pain when biting on that tooth
- Dark staining spreading into the tooth around the filling
- A large filling with thin tooth walls at risk of breaking
- Food regularly catching between the filling and a neighbouring tooth
What may replace a metal filling
- A tooth-coloured composite filling for small to moderate spaces
- A ceramic inlay when the cusps are still strong
- A ceramic onlay when one or more cusps need protection
- A crown when the tooth is badly weakened or cracked
- A same-day ceramic restoration designed in our office when suitable
- A temporary filling while a larger restoration is prepared
- Gum or bite treatment first if it affects the result
- Continued monitoring if the filling is still sound
Thoughtful restorative care
Reviewing older fillings for Guelph patients.
Because Ironwood Dental has been part of the Guelph community for more than 25 years, we often care for patients whose fillings were placed long before tooth-coloured materials were common. At 570 Kortright Rd W, we review those fillings at your exam and help you plan replacements in an order that suits your teeth and your schedule.
Related services
Related restorative options
Questions patients ask
Metal filling replacement FAQs
Patients often have questions about safety, timing, and what replaces an amalgam filling. Here are our answers.
Should I replace all my metal fillings?
Not necessarily. If a metal filling is intact, sealing well, and the tooth is healthy, it may be fine to leave it and monitor it. We recommend replacement based on the condition of each filling and tooth.
Are silver amalgam fillings safe?
Health authorities, including Health Canada, do not recommend removing sound amalgam fillings for safety reasons alone. Health Canada has suggested that some people, such as those who are pregnant, have kidney problems, or have a mercury allergy, may consider other materials for new fillings. If you have a specific health concern, we are happy to talk it through and coordinate with your physician.
Is removing an amalgam filling safe?
We use water spray and high-volume suction to keep the area clean and limit what you breathe in or swallow while the old filling is removed. If you have particular concerns, let us know before your appointment.
What will my tooth be filled with instead?
Most often a tooth-coloured composite resin. For larger areas, an inlay, onlay, or crown made from ceramic may give better strength and longevity.
Does replacing a metal filling hurt?
The tooth is frozen, so most patients feel vibration and pressure rather than pain. Some mild sensitivity afterward is common and usually fades within days to a few weeks.
Can I replace several fillings in one visit?
Sometimes, especially if they are on the same side of the mouth. We plan visits so the amount of work is comfortable for you and allows us to do each restoration carefully.
Why does my tooth look darker around my old silver filling?
Amalgam can cause a grey shadow in the surrounding tooth over time. Sometimes this is only cosmetic, but it can also hide decay, so we check it with an exam and x-rays.
Will insurance cover replacing metal fillings?
Coverage varies by plan and often depends on whether replacement is needed for clinical reasons. We can provide the details you need to check with your insurer before treatment.

